Home > Ask Our Experts > Composting Toilet: Clean Enough for Environment Agency?

Composting Toilet: Clean Enough for Environment Agency?

By: James Murray-White - Updated: 17 Feb 2019 | comments*Discuss
Composting Toilet: Clean Enough For Environment Agency?


I would like to build my own composting toilet to save on waste going into my septic tank. We are in a groundwater protection zone - SPZ2 so the Environment Agency wouldn't be impressed if we allowed anything nasty out.

If we made a DIY toilet with a seat and bucket what would you put in the bucket to allow the compost process to happen and would the resulting compost be clean enough for the EA?

(S.D, 2 April 2009)


Great! You should be commended for considering installing or creating your own composting toilet. Amongst the many reasons for their benefits to the environment are that they reduce domestic water use, cut down on chemicals and pollutants going into the septic system and then eventually the ground water, and finally demonstrate that human waste actually does have a benefit, and can be reused, rather than just casually flushed away, out of site, out of mind.

Recent developments in agriculture show that human urine can easily be used as fertiliser, saving money in researching and developing chemical options, and being so much better for the plants and soil - and ultimately us, the food or plant consumer! It is a joyful and natural process to either pee directly onto a home compost system, or to store it to pour into the rotting vegetable matter: the acids and enzymes in urine break down living organic matter quickly.

You are right however that the Environment Agency wouldn't be happy if anything from a homemade system got into the groundwater system - some breakdown and decomposition process of human waste needs to happen safely to destroy any bugs, parasites or potentially damaging viruses that can pass through our bodies.

Most of the written material I have read about this process recommend separating dry and wet waste within the home composting toilet. This might involve 2 toilets, or 2 collection buckets, or separating the toilet seat into 2. What goes into the buckets and how they are stored needs to be researched thoroughly, as different experts recommend different systems. Certainly for issues of smell, most home compost toilet users buy bags of sawdust, and throw this in after use. This also helps stick to the waste, much like cat litter has been developed. Other home compost toilet users collect local wood shavings, or shredded paper, leaves....something like this which maintain some decorum in the bucket!

I would recommend thorough research through finding books at your local library, and visit any local ecological and environmental education centre, which may well have a home composting toilet system in operation. Ask around - you never know which friends or family may have one, and be very happy to talk you through the process, and particularly if they mention any pros or cons about their system. It is far better with a subject like this to talk to those who have built one, and see the system in operation. Good luck, and congratulations again for choosing to use this more natural system!

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Hello, My wife and I have been using a compost toilet for the last 2 years. It is simple, elegant, low maintenance and produces wonderful compost. I recommend the book 'Humanure' as a bible on this matter. We simple add non-kiln dried sawdust after each usage. We built a simple wooden box with a bucket and toilet seat. Your compost heap will contain your humanure waste from the toilet (with all the sawdust you will have been adding) your food scraps and also leaves, grass etc to make sure each new deposit on the compost heap is completely covered. If it is well managed no one will have any idea that you are doing this, it doesn't smell! Create a 2 chamber compost bin so you can fill up one for a year, then leave it, use the other and then empty the first one a year later. We have just been potting out seedlings with our humanure compost, a true closed loop system.
Oneshitatatime - 17-Feb-19 @ 6:44 PM
I'm aware of a big old chapel sat empty for 5 years because there's no room for a septic tank onsite. There's only a few feet of curtilage round the building and owners of neighbouring fields won't cooperate. Is there a decent, safe, eco-friendly alternative strategy to deal with grey water and sewage within the bounds of such a place? Thank you!
z - 23-Oct-18 @ 12:05 AM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • N1G3I.fortnite
    Re: The Problem With Fossil Fuels
    I can hear my mommy makin g noises in the toilets and I am very scared hell i think she is dying. I think she took her head…
    10 December 2019
  • Erektyle desfounktio
    Re: The Problem With Fossil Fuels
    Very informative. I ileqrnt about my dad's virginity and I have never been happier to hear about Aids.
    10 December 2019
  • Bev
    Re: Underground Construction
    I have lived in an underground home in michigan for 20 years. Built in 1979. I love it. Doesnt need much heat nor air in summer. A…
    4 December 2019
  • Jake
    Re: Underground Construction
    I know of hand dug chalk mine tunnels at Scotia Nebraska under a very large hill. It is open for tours/exploration even though large…
    2 December 2019
  • RowieB
    Re: What Are Green Mortgages?
    I have just acquired 6 acres of land in Wales, which has 2 large sheds and 2 small sheds, water and electricity connected and I want…
    18 November 2019
  • atip
    Re: Grants and Loans for Green Development
    I asm looking at getting a grant to build a single new house. Are there any grants available for this? Thank you for…
    11 November 2019
  • Mike
    Re: Reclaimed Materials
    This is a cheeky message... Nextdoor neighbour of a friend of mine (naively) has been taken for £6000 by a pair of builders who wouldn't even…
    6 October 2019
  • Siddh
    Re: Sustainable Lighting
    My name is Siddh Patel and I attend Queen Elizabeth's School for Boys in London, England. For my exam in product design, I would like to…
    5 October 2019
  • Stoner
    Re: Stone Construction
    You're wrong by saying slate is only suitable for roofs and floors. I build with slate stone all the time. Local Cornish quarrys have a many…
    20 September 2019
  • Alf
    Re: Stone Construction
    It is worth remembering that the villages of Groby and Swithland in North Leicestershire are on slate outcrops. Groby slate was used by the…
    10 September 2019